NEWS

"Classic" Threshold vs. Opposed Rolls

  • 1 Replies
  • 170 Views

Lipe82

  • *
  • Newb
  • *
  • Posts: 43
« on: (17:56:40/06-03-19) »
Guys, have anyone tried to run SR:Anarchy with the traditional thresholds of SR5 (as opposed to Anarchy's opposed rolls for everything)?

What was your mileage/thoughts?
Did it "ruin" the game at any rate?
Share your experiences.

Tecumseh

  • *
  • Prime Runner
  • *****
  • Posts: 3765
« Reply #1 on: (00:14:02/06-04-19) »
I prefer the more traditional threshold type of rolling when a PC isn't actively being opposed. I like the randomness to be one-sided (i.e. on the PC's side) when they're trying to overcome an inanimate object, like a door lock. Inanimate objects rolling well to "resist" always seemed a bit goofy to me. A lock is a lock and the difficulty should be fixed rather than varying from one moment to the next. That's my preference anyway.

I can't remember the exact circumstances but I think we had a B&E expert with 10+ dice only get one hit with the 4-dice lock got four. One hit was an embarrassing roll, and statistically improbable, but it should have been enough.