Yes, it is insane, but as Al saw it, it was going for Solo, so it doesn't matter if I get burned to a crisp, gotta help the chummer.
Plus Al hates demons.
Plus, he thinks he can't die.
Anyway, I am being totally unclear.
I don't mind if bad fire spirit attacks me.
Done - I got five successes and dodged that.
Then we get to second pass - nice succubus attacks first on 15, then Al attacks on 8.
So since you first rolled a 4 for bad spirit's defense, and then later you rolled 6 hits, seems obvious you should use the 4 hits to defend against the succubus, then the 6 hits to defend against Al.