Okay then, I am in another IRL end of term paper crunch at the moment, so I will expect you three to post what you are doing and I will follow your lead.
Things to remember:
You are not trying not to get arrested or straight kill anyone, cuz that would be bad.
Icarus can and will do something to disguise himself, but the rest of you have no real ability to do so, so remember you are, literally, palefaces deep in indian country and that with the relatively high profile of your cover story, you will likely be ID'd within the day if things get loud.
The silver lining to this dark cloud, You are hell hounds in a flock of mundane sheep. Highly skilled trained professionals, and there is very little that anyone in this rinky-dink town can do to you if you don't want them to.