"Scary" is actually his character concept. *Grin*
The math works out something like this: Bad Rep +3, Merc Creedo +2, Addiction (Mild) +1.
He's got several other Qualities that probably should have a negative impact on his Rep, like a couple of Poor Self-Controls, Bad Vibe, Critter Spook, and Astral Hazing.
PS - Yes, I am aware of how bad Notoriety 6 is and the severity of my Negative Qualities. My GM is okay with it. I also have a character in reserve, in case those Negative Qualities all catch up with him at the same time.
FYI I love the storytelling component 
Mechanically, though....
A) Isn't this WAY over the 35BP CharGen cap for negative qualities?
B) Qualities don't stack notoriety on themselves. If you have Bad Rep (Rating 3), that's only 1 point of Notoriety.
Exception: If you've taken the same NQ twice (eg Poor Self Control for different options) then these would stack, however most GM's don't allow the same NQ to be aken twice in the first place.
Thanks. So far, he's a lot of fun to play.
Mechanics:
A) Yes, very. This character has 60BP in Negative Qualities, and 75BP in Positive Qualities.
Negative
35BP (Base) + 10BP (Hobgoblin - Vindictive) + 15BP (SURGE III) = 60BP
Positive
35BP (Base) + 5BP (Hobgoblin - Fangs) + 30BP (SURGE III) + 10 Karma (Character Quiz) = 75BP
SURGE III Changelings typically have a theme, often animalistic. My GM allowed me to base his theme on being emotionally radioactive - he goes into the SURGE event an Operator with severe PTSD exhibited via aggression and comes out a Hobgoblin who radiates a palpable aura of...well...
bad. Combined with his mundane Negative Qualities, such as Bad Rep and Addiction, he's a pariah.
I only allowed him one contact - a surviving member of his old unit who still owes him a few...and even her Loyalty is less than you'd expect from a comrade-in-arms. He called in his next-to-last marker just to get his first gig with the team.
B) Bad Rep has no rating, it simply adds 3 Notoriety. Poor Self-Control explicitly states that you can take it multiple times for different options, such as Poor Self-Control (Vindictive) and Poor Self-Control (Combat Monster). I don't recommend it - it's a particularly bad stew of traits - but for a guy who's rage and hostility form their own Aspected Domain, I felt it appropriate. I also gave him WIL 5 and picked up Mercenary Creedo to help keep his aggression in check.
So far, he hasn't failed a composure check...and he's only Tasered a couple of people. Well, just the one guy...twice. And the first time it was because he scored a double Critical Success on his Intimidate roll and the guy tried to throw himself out of a speeding van to get away, so...really...it was out of concern for the guy's safety. Well, that, and he was wearing my cuffs. Those things aren't
free, you know.
The second time he Tasered him for mouthing off. But I figure, hey, hello!
Hobgoblin! That should be a big enough warning sign to keep your wise-ass remarks to yourself...especially if said Hobgoblin has just kidnapped you, has already zapped you once, and is
actually radiating an aura of primordial evil. Maybe it's time for the "Don't tase me, bro!" approach, instead?
-Jn-
Ifriti Sophist